It’s easy to pretend we are listening to a person, but we are actually just waiting to correct their dodgy thinking…. We are so sure of our world-view that in a millisecond we can see where they have “gone wrong” and can’t wait to get them back on the path of truth…
The danger we daily confront however is that post-modernism, where it has been accepted as “doctrine” has blurred all the old boundaries and in its passionate abolition of absolutes, God, and what its apostles call “dated thinking”, it has created a chaos that sucks many into the abyss of despair. When you are working with depressed people it is often helpful to reflect whether, given their world-view, or the viewpoint they have been indoctrinated with, they probably should be depressed. As Frankl said so well, “there are certain things, if they happen to you and you don’t lose your mind its only because you didn’t have a mind to lose”.
There is a line to walk here, where for the survival and recovery of mental health for the client we may be professionally required to challenge their foundation. How can we be sensitive, thoughtful, respectful and truthful….? We hear Pilate in the background of course saying, “What is truth?” Old labels for depression and anxiety may have been unhelpful for some, but let’s not in any politically correct passion replace them with things that are actually not helpful at all for those suffering, who we are actually supposed to be there to help.
I am coming back to one question that cuts through a lot of time wasting in the “therapeutic process – “Will it help?” Whatever we are thinking about or articulating, be thinking always, is this actually helpful to the client? What thoughts, emotions, actions, beliefs might be useful in motivating and moving the client forward – any momentum may be useful, even if it may appear to run downhill for a time. All “labels” we use are only “sea-anchors” in a storm, designed to stabilize ready for more affirmative and positive action that will get the momentum back to the client. I keep coming back to the “Circle of Courage”, and asking what will build health, fitness, connectivity to others, altruism, skills that can be celebrated in creativity…? In short anything that gets the client active rather than passive will have us heading in a direction that has hope at its heart and finally, inspite of post-modernism BS its HOPE we all desperately need to feel communicated from any significant “other”.